God @ Rs.50/- (GST included)
It is very common to come across videos on Social media
showing
young men and women organizing food drives , clothes drives , hair cutting
drives ,clean bath drives & providing
clean clothing to shrunken ,destitute
people .. .
The philanthropic efforts deserve to be
appreciated., However, applying some perverse logic one can also conclude that the act of compassion itself can
prove detrimental to the recipient. Psychologically, passersby
would rather give alms to an emaciated, dirty looking person with matted hair & tattered clothes slouched on the footpaths more willingly, than to someone who
is well groomed, wearing good
/fancy clothes. Thus the recipient of one off
act of kindness loses his/her ‘Privilege’(entitlement? USP ?) to beg for alms.
For idle, nosy loiterers snooping around to stay occupied, events like the above provide enough grist to conjure up several ideas.
Having watched a “ show of Kindness” performed by a group of energetic young people wearing matching T shirts emblazoned “ we care”. Malappa Karadi(Karaadi ?) sitting on a stone bench , tossing peanuts steadily into his mouth suddenly hit upon an idea. He too would indulge in some “ act of kindness” and conduct an experiment..
The next morning Malappa Karadi and a friend, (another Laggard) with a Gopro camera strapped on forehead arrived at a busy Road junction. The experiment would involve 10 “selected ” people in pitiable condition.carefully selected by him: a) an old man lying on the grass in a park b) middle aged woman with infant walking aimlessly up and down in front of a small hotel c) A very frail looking young man with shopping bags hanging on both hands , trying to sell his wares at the entrance of a flower market. d) e) f) and g) haggard looking men with push carts selling trinkets, cut fruits,cheap plastic items etc. h) A woman bent double with age trying to sell hairpins & combs. & i) J) old couple watching over footwear in front of the roadside Ganesha shrine . Malappa Karadi purchased 10 packets of breakfast & 10 bottles of packaged water at a small hotel. His simple experiment would be to give each one of his first eight “Respondants” a packet each, draw them into conversation and elicit answers to his question” Do you believe in God?” In the last case he would first extract responses and only later present the packets( that is ,if possible) .All the while Laggard no.2 would be recording the “action”
Not wishing to tormenting you any further , the responses that Karadi received from his “Chosen”
respondants are as listed below
The Respondants:
a) Sir,
you are asking me the Question. Only because it has been ordained by the
supreme power,isn’t it?
b) If
it is not God, whom else should we believe? It is his blessing that I and my
child have something to eat today. God
bless you.
c) I
am running all over the place from 6.30 am. Still not sold a bag. You have given me food, at the
moment , sooo... you are God
d) Broke
into an old tamil movie song:“காசேதான் கடவுளுளடா. அந்தக் கடவுளுக்கும் அது தெரியுமடா.” and
With folded hands, looked up at the sky and uttered “அருள்
புரிவாய் அப்பனே”
e) “I
am managing a small business for the
past 15 years without much investment. I able to feed myself and my wife. It is
all HIS
grace.
f) “ God
is front of me now and has given me food.
g)
“ If a poor man like me doesn’t believe in
God, does it mean God doesn’t exist?
The
fact that a stranger like you has fed me, is enough proof”.
h) “
I’m trying to sell hairpins and combs. On most days someone like you stops by to chat with me. Like you some even give me
some food. Is this not divine
act ?,”
i)& j) As decided earlier, Malappa Karadi got
ready to try his other method
Approaching
the old couple sitting at the entrance of the temple, Karadi asks:” do you believe that God exists?” The old man replies: “Sir please give us alms!”
Maradi repeats the Question,
the old woman begs “Sir, please toss a 1 Re coin atleast”
Malappa Karadi
persists with the same Question.Gesticulating threateningly, the couple scream:” you don’t even afford to give a rupee, and here you are asking questions ! You
& your God. Go away, miser, you &*
,@@ ,&& so &
so….*&#$ (more expletives).” Sensing
that things might get worse, Karadi & his cohort place the remaining two
food packets before the old couple and flee.
The abuses heaped on him troubled Karadi a lot but the irreverent
words “You & your GOD” uttered by the couple
brought some consolation “Your
God” sounded pleasing !
Did they really mean he “Owned” God?
2 comments:
Oh dear ! That brilliant analysis that good clothes and grooming could prove detrimental to their “busines”had never occured to me ! Now i understand that common enough comment : “He looks good and healthy , why is he begging , lazy fellow!” . No wonder , the moment the Good Samaritans leave the spot , the beneficiaries go back to their original avatars . ( which , by the way, can provide opportunity for more “I Care” campaigns, more media content , more momentary rush of Self-Satisfying nobility .
I think i have seen this “ Karadi “ species , albeit under different names , running riot in social media 😁
Enjoyed reading .
Good one mama!A memory bubbles up. Ramu Tatha once told me,"God helps those who helps themselves." This was in the context of me asking him why he didn't give a poor beggar money. Then I used this phrase on Appa when he asked me to get him some water after returning from work. And naturally got severely scolded by Amma and was also told that the consequence of this bad deed was reincarnation as a palli! Hope the tatasthu devathe was not listening! OMG pl save poor lil ol me!
Post a Comment